The first state to enact legislation specifically banning certain out-of-state travel for abortions is Idaho.
The new law makes it a crime to assist a juvenile who is pregnant in getting an abortion in another state, whether by medicine or a surgical procedure. The law was approved by the governor on Wednesday night, and it becomes effective after 30 days.
Since August, Idaho has prohibited abortion at all stages of pregnancy as a consequence of the Supreme Court’s decision to reverse Roe v. Wade. Pregnancy termination is banned in the state unless it saves the mother’s life or if the victim of rape or incest has reported the crime to authorities.
Idaho’s legislation is the first that clearly criminalizes aiding in an out-of-state abortion, even though Oklahoma and Texas permit lawsuits against anyone who enable an abortion inside their boundaries.
“Giving [minors] money, giving them a ride, helping them organize the visit to a doctor out of state — all of the activity that’s required to help a young person leave the state — any of that would be punishable,” said Elisabeth Smith, the director of U.S. state policy and advocacy at the Center for Reproductive Rights.
Mistie DelliCarpini-Tolman, Idaho state director of Planned Parenthood Alliance Advocates, claims that as a result of the bill’s passing, Idaho now has the most stringent abortion laws in the country.
Throughout her career, she stated, “House Bill 242 may be the most radical law I’ve ever seen.”
Legal experts have predicted moves from conservative politicians to further limit access to abortion since the Supreme Court’s Casey ruling last year. He said that Idaho has now laid forth a blueprint for other states to follow.
“For a long time, there has been this sort of jockeying of which state could have the most oppressive laws on abortion,” she said. “For that reason, I think Idaho could be an example to anti-abortion lawmakers.”
A tweet was posted in which Gretchen Whitmer told about the three bills:
"Who wants to watch me slay a zombie?" – Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D) signing three bills killing the state's 92-year-old anti-abortion law. pic.twitter.com/XdCHVfbtkt
— Heartland Signal (@HeartlandSignal) April 5, 2023
Angry Discussion About The New Legislation
The new legislation in Idaho allows people who assist a child in getting an abortion a legitimate defense against prosecution provided the parents gave their permission.
One justification for the rule, according to David Ripley, executive director of Idaho Chooses Life, a political action organization that supports anti-abortion legislation, is that children are unable to make their own educated choices about any kind of medical treatment.
“When you’re talking about a minor being transported across state lines, especially for a medical procedure without parental consent, I think that is clearly within the authority of the state of Idaho to criminalize and discourage,” Ripley said.
Nevertheless, proponents of abortion rights believe the measure might pave the way for regulations targeting anyone who assists adults in getting out-of-state abortions in the future.
“That is the way, historically, all abortion restrictions have begun: by first limiting young people’s access, and then moving to adult access,” Smith said.
DelliCarpini-Tolman said Planned Parenthood will be “examining every angle that we can to fight this legislation.”
“The mere suggestion that the state would consider prosecuting someone for assisting a young person accessing safe, legal medical care in another state flies in the face of our democratic system and sets a dangerous statutory precedent,” she added.
A Court Fight Involving Neighboring States
Idaho is not the first state to make an effort to restrict the rights of citizens to support individuals seeking abortions outside of the state.
A clause that would have made it unlawful for someone to assist a Missouri citizen in getting an abortion outside of the state was proposed by Missouri legislators in a wider abortion bill in 2021. The clause was, however, rejected by the state’s House of Representatives.
As a lawsuit challenging the state’s abortion prohibition is being heard in court, a federal judge in Texas also temporarily barred prosecutors from pressing charges against those who assist in out-of-state abortions.
On the other hand, states that allow abortion have fought for laws to safeguard visitors from other states who seek abortions within their borders.
A measure that would prevent courts and law enforcement from complying with warrants, subpoenas, or other court orders from states requesting information on abortions carried out in Washington for non-residents is now being debated in the state Senate of Washington. A similar bill is being considered in Oregon.
According to Smith, these so-called shield laws may make it more difficult for Idaho prosecutors to develop charges involving out-of-state abortions.
Washington lawmakers are anticipated to vote on the state’s shield bill at any moment, according to Paul Dillon, the departing vice president of public relations at Planned Parenthood of Greater Washington and North Idaho.
To ensure that such safeguards are in place before this Idaho legislation takes effect, Dillon said, “It does seem like a race, I guess.”
In the meantime, he said, patients traveling to Planned Parenthood facilities in Washington are not obliged to reveal their origin or their companions. According to residence information provided, there was a 75% rise in Idaho patients visiting Washington state clinics from January 2022 to early 2023.
You may also read about California in the following news outlets:
- Rfk Jr. Declares His Candidacy for President on the Democratic Party’s Ballot
- Crime Victims in Arizona Were Denied a Stay of Execution by the State’s Highest Court
Access To Maternal Health Care Might Is Impacted By Idaho’s Anti-abortion Legislation
According to a recent letter from the state’s attorney general, Idaho’s abortion prohibition may make it illegal for health professionals to recommend women for abortions outside of the state. A collection of service providers, including Planned Parenthood, submitted a court objection to that interpretation on Thursday.
Abortion opponents claim that Idaho’s anti-abortion legislation is already having negative side effects, such as limiting access to reproductive health care.
Last month, two hospitals in Idaho made the announcement that their labor and delivery departments would be shutting. One of them, Bonner General Health, said in a press statement that the closure was brought on by a lack of pediatricians and the state of affairs in Idaho.
“The Idaho Legislature continues to introduce and pass bills that criminalize physicians for medical care nationally recognized as the standard of care,” the statement said.
Medical professionals said that because of the closures, patients must travel farther for reproductive care, endangering their health in an emergency. The nearest Idaho hospital with a labor & delivery unit from Bonner General Health is 45 miles away.
If you’re interested in keeping up with the newest news and reading more from the California Examiner, follow their Twitter handle